Which mattress is better: springless or spring mattress, how not to make the wrong choice

To ensure a full-fledged comfortable rest, the main condition is high-quality sleeping furniture, for which it is necessary to choose the right sleeping surface. Products are presented in a wide range and differ in filling, rigidity, anatomical and orthopedic properties. Which mattress is better: springless or innerspring? It will be possible to answer the question after studying the distinctive features of each type of product.

Modern mattresses are divided into spring and springless

Bonnel spring block: what is it

To understand the question of which mattress is better: springless or spring-loaded, you should study the structure and characteristics of the products. The base of the spring product is a metal frame consisting of springs. There are two types of mattresses, which differ in the options for connecting spirals, their shape, size and method of attaching them to the frame, and therefore they are divided into mattresses with dependent and independent springs. The first option is represented by products with a Bonnel spring block, and the second with a Pocket Spring system.

The spring block will support the shape of the mattress and resist sagging, while making it elastic and giving it softness and firmness

Bonnel's spring mattress was invented over a century ago. It consists of spirals interconnected. The springs are made of high quality steel wire 1.2-2.5 mm in diameter. Each element consists of 4-5 turns with a diameter of up to 10 cm.

To create coils, the technology of fastening bicone springs is used, where the coil radius periodically increases and decreases. Here one of two options is used - four-turn or five-turn weaving. In the latter case, the spring block is slightly higher, as a result of which the product will cost more.

The springs are tapered at the center and widened at the edges, giving them an hourglass-like appearance. This design allows you to evenly distribute the load of the human body, while maintaining its correct position.To connect the spirals to each other, a high-carbon steel wire with knots or a special metal frame is used. To prevent unauthorized unwinding of the springs on the first and last turns, attachment to the block, consisting of the lower and upper frame, is performed.

Important! Special locks are made on the turns of the end spirals, which increase the strength of the block.

The Bonnel spring block is a set of rigidly interconnected 5-turn spirals

Bonnel springs are intertwined in a certain sequence, so that they do not come into contact with each other, which eliminates the likelihood of friction and the occurrence of a characteristic grinding during operation of the product. The number of springs in 1 sq. m can reach 100-150 pieces, depending on the model and manufacturer of the product.

Advantages and disadvantages of Bonnel bed spring mattresses

As numerous reviews prove, the Bonnel spring block is very popular among consumers, who note the good performance of the mattress and its affordable cost.

The Bonnel spring block is distinguished by its high reliability and durability, averaging 15-20 years. This is achieved through a special method of twisting the coils and connecting the springs to each other. The result is a rigid framework in which the spirals do not move to the side.

When a heavy load is applied to the mattress, the spirals do not touch each other and are not pressed down to the base. This elasticity avoids friction and squeaking. The springs are capable of supporting a single person's weight of 120 kg or more.

The main function of the mattress is the ability to support the spine in the correct position.

It is recommended to purchase a sleeping surface with a system of dependent springs for a child. There is a special line of spring mattresses for children, which, while being moderately firm, are able to provide adequate support for the child's spine without causing discomfort to the muscles of the back and hips.

Due to the hollow structure of the Bonnel, proper ventilation is ensured. Good air permeability reduces the likelihood of metal corrosion, bacteria and insects, which increases the hygiene of the product.

Layers of fillers in the form of felt, polyurethane, wool, coconut fiber, padding polyester, batting, spunbond and other materials are laid on the spring base, which provide additional comfort, soften the feeling of springs and at the same time adjust the rigidity of the structure.

Important! The Bonnel block is mainly used in the manufacture of in-spring sofas.

Bonnel provides the mattress with a high level of reliability and elasticity

The disadvantages of products with the Bonnel spring system include, first of all, imperfect orthopedic properties. During the operation of the mattress, the springs, which constantly perceive the load, are compressed, which creates the effect of a hammock. This deformation of the sleeping surface is especially noticeable on double products. The discomfort from the presence of a depression is felt by the second partner, who is on an inclined surface, as a result of which the muscles reflexively contract.

Useful advice! To avoid the hammock effect, it is recommended to turn the mattress periodically.

Sometimes, when the spring block receives constant heavy loads, some of the springs can break or straighten, which will damage the filler and the cover. It will be impossible to sleep on such a mattress.

After several years of operation, an unpleasant squeak may appear, which is the result of loosening of the spring mount. To prevent this from happening, many manufacturers reinforce the spring block with layers of dense polyurethane foam.This technique allows you to increase the permissible load on the mattress up to 180 kg, and also extends the life of the product.

The design is capable of withstanding a large weight, so it can be safely used by people weighing more than 115 kg

Features of the mattress with an independent spring block

The block of independent springs is represented by the Pocket Spring system. Each barrel-shaped or cylindrical coil is made of hardened high-carbon steel with a diameter of 1.5-2 mm. The number of turns in the spring is 8 pieces, their diameter is 2-6 cm. For 1 sq. m of them are located from 250 to 1000 pieces. The best option is 350 pcs. for 1 m² of surface.

Each spring is housed in a separate cover made of non-woven material in the form of fibertex or spunbond. The springs do not interact with each other. To create a holistic structure, the covers themselves are interconnected. The binding of the springs should be extremely concentric, which will allow each element to show its elasticity, thereby achieving the maximum anatomical effect.

Each spring is housed in a separate cover made of non-woven fabric and does not come into contact with adjacent springs

When considering which springs are better, you should pay attention to the fact that the Pocket Spring system helps to create the maximum orthopedic effect, where every part of the human body is supported to the required degree. The mattress follows the shape of the entire body, ensuring its correct position and good blood circulation.

Important! To create the correct geometric shape and obtain the required size of the product, the structure is complemented on both sides with a spunbond layer.

Classification of mattresses with independent springs

Blocks with independent springs are of different types, which affects the final cost of the product.

The simplest and most common option is the Pocket Spring S500 block. It consists of springs with a diameter of 5-6 cm, the number of which per 1 sq. m is 220-300 pcs. Such a mattress assumes a maximum load on one berth of up to 120 kg.

For 1 sq. m of a mattress with a Micropocket block, there are about 1200 spirals

A more advanced option is the Multipocket block, which has a much higher spring density. This contributes to improved anatomical function. The structure includes springs up to 4 cm in diameter. For 1 sq. m can accommodate up to 500 pieces. The mattress has a maximum load capacity of 135 kg.

A spring orthopedic mattress with a Micropocket block is equipped with miniature springs with a diameter of 2-2.5 cm, which allow you to achieve the maximum density of the structure. For 1 sq. m there are up to 1200 spirals. Such a block can withstand a load of up to 150 kg. Due to the presence of point elasticity, the mattress perfectly follows the contours of the body.

One of the latest advances in orthopedic sleep products is the Housе Glass mattress with independent springs. The springs are in the shape of an hourglass. Such elements are characterized simultaneously by three degrees of rigidity, which makes it possible to implement them in double models designed for partners with a significant difference in weight categories.

Another suitable option for couples with a large difference in weight is the Dual Spring mattress. A distinctive feature of the products is that two springs are located in one case - one in the other. A spiral with a larger diameter is characterized by less rigidity, and the second is high.

Mattresses with an independent spring block have a specific design, which is based on a block consisting of individual cylindrical springs

Important! If one or more of the springs are damaged, the manufacturer can repair the spring mattress.

Reinforced Pocket Spring mattresses are made of thick wire with a diameter of 3-4 mm. Models withstand weight up to 160 kg.There are options with different zones of stiffness, which makes it possible to provide more accurate support for the body of a large person.

Pros and cons of mattresses with an independent spring block

A mattress with an independent spring block has a number of distinctive advantages. Due to the fact that each spring is located in a separate case, such a product is characterized by improved anatomical properties. There is no hammock effect here.

Important! The more springs in 1 sq. m, the higher the ability of the mattress to adapt to the anatomical curves of the human body.

An important advantage of an independent spring unit is the absence of friction of the springs, and therefore, you cannot hear an unpleasant squeak

The mattress with independent springs is characterized by a durability exceeding 20 years. Products are safe. The presence of a durable cover for each spring eliminates the possibility of element breakage, the sharp edge of which could break through the filler and cover and injure a sleeping person.

Another undoubted advantage of independent spring units is their ability to withstand significant loads, which cannot be said about mattresses without springs. They do not sag under a person weighing up to 100 kg. There are models designed for a load of 200 kg.

Related article:

Sizes of mattresses for a bed: how not to make a mistake when choosing a product

Dimensions of standard and non-standard products. Selection of the width, length and height of the mattress depending on the age, height and complexion of a person.

The products are characterized by a low level of movement transmission, which is especially valuable for double products. When one spouse rolls over, the other will not feel the hesitation effect. Due to the wide variety of products, it becomes possible to choose the appropriate option for a married couple with a large difference in weight.

During operation, an unpleasant squeak does not appear, since each spring is isolated from its neighbors, which eliminates the possibility of friction.

Mattress maintains anatomically correct body position, providing a comfortable resting environment

However, mattresses with an independent spring block are not without drawbacks. First of all, the high cost of the products should be noted. These types of mattresses are not recommended for small children. This is due to the fact that such a product is characterized by the ability to take high loads, so it will be too tough for a child.

Pros and cons of springless mattresses

Springless mattresses have no metal frame. They are made from various types of fillers. The necessary rigidity, elasticity and orthopedic properties are provided due to a certain combination of layers among themselves. As evidenced by numerous reviews, springless mattresses are more comfortable than their spring counterparts.

Such products are characterized by durability and safety. As fillers, hypoallergenic materials are used that do not cause skin irritation. The mattress is devoid of metal elements that can break during its use. Also, this design eliminates the possibility of friction or characteristic squeak. The service life of a soft springless mattress is no more than 10 years. A hard product can last about 15 years.

In springless models of mattresses, both artificial and natural fillers are used.

The mattress is lightweight, which makes it easy to transport. A springless product does not need special care, ventilation and extraction of dust from its cavities. It is enough to carry out preventive cleaning once a year.

Of the shortcomings of the products, one can single out the limitation on weight. The highest quality hard springless mattress will not withstand a load of more than 120 kg without losing its orthopedic properties.High quality products are characterized by a high cost, which can exceed the price of mattresses with independent springs. According to the technology, separate layers of different materials are connected to each other using an adhesive that has an unpleasant odor. However, it will disappear a few days after the product is removed from the package.

Latex, foam rubber, coconut coir, bamboo, struttofiber, sea grass, horse hair are used as fillers for such mattresses. Products can be soft, medium hardness and hard, which is determined by the type and sequence of layers of material.

The main advantage of the springless mattress is the orthopedic effect

Natural fillers for springless mattresses

The most popular products are latex and coconut coir products. Latex is made from the juice of Brazilian hevea. Its structure resembles a honeycomb, which is formed as a result of foaming and vulcanization of the material. The cells have different diameters, due to which the material is characterized by a different degree of rigidity, which is transmitted to the springless mattress. Latex has air pockets that ensure good air circulation.

A mattress made of this material has the ability to retain and give off heat in the winter, and it does not heat up in the summer.

Important! Latex is a rather soft material, therefore it is used in combination with coconut fiber.

To obtain a mattress of medium hardness, latex is placed on top of a layer of coconut fiber, and to increase the rigidity of the product, latex is placed under this layer. You can choose a combined option, which is often used for children's springless mattresses, where the product has a two-sided orientation with different levels of firmness.

Latex mattresses are some of the best on the market today.

Coconut fiber mattresses are mainly used for newborns who have not yet developed posture. The products are characterized by the required level of rigidity, moisture resistance and good air permeability.

Rigid springless horsehair mattresses, which are recommended for people with spinal problems: osteochondrosis, rheumatism, are gaining popularity. There are models with cotton filling. If short fibers are used, the mattress will be thick, heavy and short-lived. Long fibers will provide lightness and long product life.

Artificial fillers for springless mattresses

Polyurethane foam, technogel, struttofiber, holofiber and memorform are used as synthetic fillers for the mattress. Furniture foam rubber is considered a non-toxic material with a porous cellular structure. This is the cheapest filler option.

Memoriform is a type of polypropylene foam. The material is able to memorize the outlines of the human body. It is elastic, hypoallergenic, wear-resistant, durable, has medicinal orthopedic qualities. The disadvantages include the high cost of the product. The price of such a springless mattress 200x200 cm reaches 35 thousand rubles.

Polyurethane foam mattresses maximally follow the body contour

Holofiber is characterized by medium hardness. Thanks to the spiral fibers, the mattress has good elasticity and orthopedic effect. The material is able to retain heat. This mattress is affordable.

Structofiber has a fibrous structure characterized by a vertical arrangement of fibers. It is characterized by wear resistance, breathability and durability. The main disadvantage is the lack of the ability to bend the mattress. Technogel is an innovative material that is able to completely repeat the outlines of the human body, thereby achieving the maximum orthopedic effect. However, these mattresses are quite expensive.

Which is better: spring or springless mattress, Comparative characteristics

In order to decide which mattress to choose: spring or springless, - it is necessary to analyze and compare some indicators of the products.

The first criterion is the likelihood of dust getting into the indoor unit and accumulating in it. Springless mattresses are devoid of large voids, and micropores do not have communicating cells. This design feature prevents dust from entering. The inner block of the product is protected by a heat-regulating, hypoallergenic layer, which acts as a dust filter that keeps dust trapped under the cover. It can be easily removed with a vacuum cleaner.

The main difference between springless mattresses is less elasticity, they are chosen by people who do not like the "pushing" effect of springs

The spring block of the mattress is characterized by the presence of a large number of voids that create a pump effect. After 2-3 years, the inner frame will resemble a dust-filled vacuum cleaner bag.

When choosing a spring mattress or polyurethane foam mattress, one cannot ignore the possibility of static electricity in it. The springless mattress is an electrobiological product. It does not contain metallic elements, which eliminates the possibility of static electricity.

Useful advice! To eliminate the accumulation of static electricity for springless models, you should choose a cover made of natural material.

The presence of metal products in spring mattresses leads to the formation of static stress, which negatively affects human health. This can lead to irritability, depression, increased fatigue and sleep disturbance.

Spring mattresses have many advantages, they are made using modern materials and technologies

Which mattress is better: springless or spring mattress, important points

Thinking about which is better: polyurethane foam or a spring block, one cannot but mention the possibility of moisture inside the mattress. The human body is designed in such a way that it releases 50-200 g of moisture during sleep. It accumulates on bed linen and the mattress cover. Some of it can get inside the product. Springless mattress covers are capable of evaporating 50-90% moisture. In such products, materials with a high level of air permeability are used as a filler, which contributes to the rapid removal of moisture from the indoor unit.

Covers of spring mattresses are able to prevent the penetration of 10-50% moisture. The rest of it gets inside, which can lead to erosion of the metal block, mainly made of ferrous metal, on which there is no anti-corrosion coating. This leads to the formation of an unfavorable microclimate. Damaged springs will make a squeaking noise.

Springless mattresses are deprived of the ability to transmit vibrational movements. The change in body position occurs locally. This also applies to mattresses with independent springs. Products with dependent metal elements will react to changes in body position, and vibrations are felt throughout the sleeping surface.

In spring mattresses, a metal block around the perimeter is reinforced, therefore it is not so comfortable to sleep on it

When deciding which mattress is better to choose: springless or spring-loaded, you should pay attention to the orthopedic properties of each type of product. The first option and mattresses with a block of independent springs are characterized by good qualities. Such products provide an even distribution of the load, create anatomical support for each part of the human body.

For mattresses with a block of dependent springs, minimal orthopedic qualities are characteristic. This is due to the fact that all springs are interconnected. When exposed to one of them, all nearby ones are triggered, which does not allow to properly provide anatomical support for the body.

The structure of the springless mattress is the same over the entire area of ​​the product. There are no restrictions on the use of the mattress edge. For spring models, the metal block is reinforced with polyurethane around the perimeter. Such a frame can be soft or hard enough, so the edges of the mattress are uncomfortable for sleeping.

To choose one or another model, you need to focus on personal needs and preferences.

Rating of mattresses with independent springs famous brands

Ormatek Hybrid is a popular, moderately soft spring mattress.. The product includes a spring block S1000, which has 1 sq. m there are 500 springs. The product has different sides in terms of filling, which allows you to change the level of rigidity, firmness and elasticity of the sleeping surface by turning the mattress.

On one side there is a combination of memoriform and natural latex layers. Under the influence of a person's weight, Memoriform remembers the individual outlines of his body and restores its shape a few seconds after the load is removed. To compensate for the inconvenience and increase the elasticity of the surface, memoriform is coated with natural latex.

On the other side of the product, a layer of polystyrene foam is laid, which provides a harder sleeping surface, which has a therapeutic effect on the muscles of the sleeping person. The mattress has a knitted non-removable cover. The product is designed for loads up to 140 kg. The cost of such a spring mattress 160x200 cm is 30 thousand rubles.

Ormatek Variant orthopedic mattress with an independent spring block for 1 sq. m there are 500 springs

Among the spring mattresses of medium firmness, the Matramax Flores model can be distinguished. The product consists of a metal frame with a block of independent springs, the number of which per 1 sq. m is 625 pcs. On both sides, layers of coconut coir are laid, framed around the perimeter and the entire sleeping area of ​​the product with durable and elastic polypropylene foam. The cover of the mattress is made of a cotton / polyester blend. The height of the product is 18 cm. You can buy a spring mattress 160x200 cm for 18 thousand rubles.

The versatile firm Ormatek Variant mattress is in great demand. The orthopedic base is represented by an independent spring block, which has 1 sq. m there are 500 springs. To change the elasticity and firmness of the product, simply turn the mattress over.

One side is very hard, which provides a 3 cm thick layer of coconut fiber. On the other side, there is a combination of fillers in the form of coconut coir and natural latex, which makes the sleeping surface moderately hard. The height of the mattress is 26 cm. It can support up to 140 kg. The price of a double model measuring 160x200 cm is 25 thousand rubles. You can also order a product in non-standard sizes. For example, a spring mattress 200x200 cm will cost 32 thousand rubles.

The preference will be on the side of the manufacturer, whose products combine excellent quality and reasonable price.

Popular models of mattresses on the Bonnel spring block

Ormatek Larda model is popular among Bonnel mattresses with moderate firmness. A block of independent springs, where 1 sq. m account for 108 elements, creates the necessary degree of elasticity. A layer of spunbond is laid on top of the springs, which is represented by a polypropylene non-woven material that is resistant to abrasion and high loads.

The sleeping surface is laid in a calico cover, which is quilted with hypoallergenic material. The mattress is designed for a load of up to 105 kg. The cost of a single product is on average 7 thousand rubles.

The Promtex-Orient Rest Standard mattress has good anatomical properties. The basis of the product is represented by a block of dependent springs of a small diameter, on top of which layers of coconut coir and polyurethane foam are laid, which gives the mattress the required rigidity.This model is made in a jacquard case. The product is designed for loads up to 90 kg. You can buy such a mattress for 8.5 thousand rubles.

If you need to purchase a product that must withstand a load of up to 120 kg, it is recommended to opt for the Comfort Line Eco model. The basis of the product is represented by the Bonnel block, which has 500 springs per 1 sq. m. It is supplemented with a layer of elastic latex coconut fiber, under which a layer of foam is laid, which prolongs the life of the product. The cotton cover provides extra comfort. The price of a spring mattress 140x200 cm is 15 thousand rubles.

Ormatek Larda mattress fits into a hypoallergenic calico cover

The best springless mattresses: rating of popular models

The first position in the rating of springless mattresses is occupied by the Ormatek Flex Standart product. Artificial latex is used here as a filler, which makes the mattress elastic, moderately hard. Such a product is capable of withstanding a heavy load. It provides anatomical support for all parts of the human body. The height of the mattress is 15 cm. It is equipped with a dense cover made of coarse calico fabric. You can buy the product for 13 thousand rubles.

A popular model is the Ormatek Flex Zone Plus Big medium firm mattress. It is made of polyurethane foam with 5 hardness zones, which provides an anatomical and massage effect. As you know from the reviews, the polyurethane foam mattress does not deform under load and quickly regains its shape. Despite the increased height of 23 cm, the product can be twisted, transported and stored in this form without fear of violating the integrity of the structure. The price of the mattress is 12 thousand rubles.

For married couples with different weight categories, a super hard mattress Dreamline Orto 15 is a good solution, which is made of coconut coir, presented in several layers. This design helps to keep the spine in the correct position. The multi-layer product is securely hidden in a jacquard cover that does not attract dust, is well cleaned of stains, and prevents the sheet from wrinkling. You can buy a springless mattress 160x200 cm for 17 thousand rubles.

Ormatek Flex Standart is filled with artificial latex, which makes the mattress moderately firm and elastic for a comfortable stay

Will help to understand the question of which mattresses are better (springless or spring), reviews of real consumers, which give an objective assessment of the product. Each type of mattress is characterized by distinctive features that must be considered when choosing a product. The main criteria are the required rigidity, elasticity, the presence of orthopedic and anatomical qualities.